Appendix H: Vendor Scoring Worksheet

This worksheet provides a structured way to score solutions against Reconstruction-Grade criteria. Scores are illustrative; enterprises should adjust weights based on risk profile.

Table 11. Scoring worksheet (fill-in)

Criterion	Weight (1-3)	Vendor Score (0-3)	Notes / Evidence
Point-in-time as-sent resolution	3		Demonstrated deterministic resolution and documented fallback rules.
Stable identifier preservation	3		Persists platform IDs; resilient to moves/renames/redirects.
Relationship integrity (Parent/Child mappings)	3		Exports explicit relationships without collapsing context.
Identity over time (effective-dated)	3		As-of identity and membership reconstruction.
Audit evidence ingestion and correlation	2		Observed access correlated to preserved objects/versions.
Deterministic exceptions and retry audit	2		Reason-coded exceptions; full retry history; deterministic end state.
Reproducible exports with manifests + hashes	3		Repeatable outputs; integrity validation.
Operational monitoring at scale	2		Throughput, throttling backoff, exception tracking, SLA reporting.
Data portability and evidence longevity	2		Supports export profiles and long-term reusability.